Many restaurants and food stores in Amish Country have bakeries, but the following are dedicated to the craft. One whiff as you step in the door, and you’ll be in heaven.
Der Bake Oven
They list 18 different types of cookies on their menu, including the triple treat and cream filled ginger.
4766 State Route 39, Berlin
Hershberger Farm and Bakery
Fans rave about their fry pies and peanut butter dream bars. Plus, they have fresh produce in season.
5452 State Route 557, Charm
This Amish-owned bakery will leave you drooling over its caramel-iced cinnamon rolls.
4280 Township Road 356, Millersburg
Olde World Bakery and Bistro
Along with an array of traditional baked goods, they boast offerings of gluten-free products and spelt products.
4363 State Route 39, Millersburg
Quince Bakery & Café
From their website: “Given an advanced notice, we can bake just about anything.” Yes, please. And if you lack patience, just dive into one of Jean Louise’s All Fruit Pies.
4776 Kidron Road, Kidron